Search This Blog

Showing posts with label India. Show all posts
Showing posts with label India. Show all posts

Thursday, 7 July 2011

The General Electric Business Screen

The General Electric Business Screen was originally developed to help marketing managers overcome the problems that are commonly associated with the Boston Matrix (BCG), such as the problems with the lack of credible business information, the fact that BCG deals primarily with commodities not brands or Strategic Business Units (SBU's), and that cashflow if often a more reliable indicator of position as opposed to market growth/share.



The GE Business Screen introduces a three by three matrix, which now includes a medium category. It utilizes industry attractivenessas a more inclusive measure than BCG's market growth and substitutes competitive position for the original's market share.
GE Business Screen
So in come Strategic Business Units (SBU's). A large corporation may have many SBU's, which essentially operate under the same strategic umbrella, but are distinctive and individual. A loose example would refer to Microsoft, with SBU's for operating systems, business software, consumer software and mobile and Internet technologies.
Growth/share are replaced by competitive position and market attractiveness. The point is that successful SBU's will go and do well in attractive markets because they add value that customers will pay for. So weak companies do badly for the opposite reasons. To help break down decision-making further, you then consider a number of sub-criteria:
For market attractiveness:
  • Size of market.
  • Market rate of growth.
  • The nature of competition and its diversity.
  • Profit margin.
  • Impact of technology, the law, and energy efficiency.
  • Environmental impact.
...and for competitive position:
  • Market share.
  • Management profile.
  • R & D.
  • Quality of products and services.
  • Branding and promotions success.
  • Place (or distribution).
  • Efficiency.
  • Cost reduction.
At this stage the marketing manager adapts the list above to the needs of his strategy. The GE matrix has 5 steps:
  • One - Identify your products, brands, experiences, solutions, or SBU's.
  • Two - Answer the question, What makes this market so attractive?
  • Three - Decide on the factors that position the business on the GE matrix.
  • Four - Determine the best ways to measure attractiveness and business position.
  • Five - Finally rank each SBU as either low, medium or high for business strength, and low, medium and high in relation to market attractiveness.
Now follow the usual words of caution that go with all boxes, models and matrices. Yes the GE matrix is superior to the Boston Matrix since it uses several dimensions, as opposed to BCG's two. However, problems or limitations include:
  • There is no research to prove that there is a relationship between market attractiveness and business position.
  • The interrelationships between SBU's, products, brands, experiences or solutions is not taken into account.
  • This approach does require extensive data gathering.
  • Scoring is personal and subjective.
  • There is no hard and fast rule on how to weight elements.
  • The GE matrix offers a broad strategy and does not indicate how best to implement it.
by Mkt Teachers

Wednesday, 6 July 2011

Benchmarking

Benchmarking relies upon a comparison between the activities of your own organization and those of another. Originally benchmarking was used in manufacturing operations where one process could be compared and contrasted with another.



Think about it in basic terms - you measure a piece of wood along your bench. You keep one end of the wood level/flush with the end of the bench and cut a notch in the bench itself with your chisel at the other end. Then you place other pieces of wood in the same location - the shorter ones you reject and the longer ones you cut down. A benchmark is a measurement tool.
Xerox is commonly cited as the original proponent. More recently the definition has broadened to include all business processes, competitive advantages, performance and strategies (Prasnikar et al 2005)
Benchmarking

Basic types of benchmark.

Competitive or Industry/sector benchmarking enables an organization to compare its performance with competitors trading in the same industry or sector.
Best-in-class benchmarking is similar to industry or sector benchmarking. However managers would compare their organization to the market or sector leader i.e. the best-in-class.
Internal or historical benchmarking is the internal procedure for comparing results from past performance to current or forecasted performance.
Functional or external benchmarking involves comparing your business activities with those of companies from other industries/sectors with similar processes.
Collaborative benchmarking involves two phases; firstly between two voluntary collaborators within a sector, then secondly between the two collaborators and a party outside the current sphere of competition. Of course this is better suited to the public sector e.g. hospitals, police services since commercial rivals are unlikely to collaborate in this manner.

Benefits of benchmarking (Gift 1996)

  • It is an effective approach for achieving operational change. Benchmarks are the catalyst that moves an organization to higher levels of performance.
  • Since customer requirements are so rigorously defined, benchmarking improves customer orientation.
  • It focuses upon the processes that improve results - not simply results.
  • Performance measures are often improved as a result of benchmarking.
  • Decision making improves because the organization has enhanced customer knowledge, process focus, and performance measures.
  • Benchmarking improves innovation and creativity since self-imposed barriers to success are removed.

Potential pitfalls with benchmarking.

  • Benchmarking needs to be supported and driven by senior leaders.
  • Prerequisites (such as organizational structure, processes) need to be in place.
  • Conducting benchmarking for the wrong reasons can be problematic e.g. to produce data - ignoring processes and insights gained into practices that produce benchmarks.
  • Selecting the wrong benchmarks.
  • Selecting the wrong benchmark partner.
  • Not gaining management support for plans resulting from benchmarks.

Marketing benchmarking.

When applying benchmarking techniques to an organization's marketing activities you are essentially comparing one or a number of your company's marketing activities to those of another part of the business, a competitor or a business that operates in another industry. Vorhies and Morgan (2005) used the following marketing benchmarks in their research:
  • Pricing
  • Product Development
  • Channel Management
  • Marketing Communications
  • Selling
  • Market Information Systems
  • Marketing Planning
  • Marketing Implementation
Essentially they focus upon the marketing mix, marketing information, planning and operations. Each of these could be sub-divided and new factors introduced e.g. Customer Relationship Management (CRM) - to suit your own organization's marketing strategy.

by Mkt Teachers

Balanced Scorecard

The Balanced Scorecard is an approach that can be used by strategic marketing managers to control, and keep track of, key performance indicators. In fact the scorecard itself is designed to be wholly strategic since it contains long-term outcomes and drivers of success. There are four zones in a balanced scorecard namely financial, customers, business processes (or simply processes), and learning and growth. Each measure is part of a longer chain of cause and effect, and all of the measures eventually lead to outcomes (read on and this will become clearer). So the scorecard is 'balanced' in that outcomes are in balance with each other.



The benefit of the scorecard is that is overcomes short-term quick fixes, and gives the strategic marketing manager a straightforward overview of the organisation. In fact, a scorecard should ideally fit onto a single sheet of paper. In fact Kaplan and Norton (1992), the originators of Balanced Scorecard, describe it as the dials in an airplane cockpit.
Balanced scorecard

Learning and Growth.

Learning and Growth deals with measures of corporate success in relation to how it learns as it develops over time. So if the company makes mistakes in any way, then it must learn from them and there must be mechanisms in place to make sure that happens. Growth also includes the way in which it generates leaders for the future and equips employees with the necessary skills that will ultimately sustain its business. Examples include skills sets, employee relations and satisfaction, and staff competences.

Internal Business Processes.

Internal business processes include all operations within the organisation. The measures would cover whether or not value is being delivered to target segments, and the value chain is tracked. Innovation and new product development would also be measured. Examples of internal business processes include Information Technology, manufacturing, marketing operations such as customer service, procurement and quality processes.

Customers.

As marketers we are very concerned with our customers. We need to make sure that they are satisfied with every aspect of their experience with our organisation. We need to make sure that we not only recruit more new customers, but that we also retain them and extend new products and services to them. We also need to make sure that we are meeting the needs of our target segments. So here, examples of customer measures include customer retention and recruitment, their satisfaction and so on.

Financial.

Financial measures are vitally important for any business. A note of caution here, since traditional measures of financial success such as Return On Investment (ROI), and made secondary to 'shareholder value.' Shareholder value is the natural measure of success, and so it is prioritised. Information on customers, markets and technology is far more widely available today, so don't bogged down with old fashioned financial measures.
Resources, individuals and teams within a business are then aligned with the scorecard objectives, measures, targets and initiatives for each of the four areas of measurement.
by Mkt Teachers

The Arthur D Little (ADL) Strategic Condition Matrix

Although now slightly dated at first glance, The Arthur D Little (ADL) Strategic Condition Matrix offers a different perspective on strategy formulation. ADL has two main dimensions - competitive position and industry maturity.



Competitive position is driven by the sectors or segments in which a Strategic Business Unit (SBU) operates. The product or service which it markets, and the accesses it has to a range of geographically dispersed markets that are what makes up an organization's competitive position i.e. product and place.
Industry maturity is very similar to the Product Life Cycle (PLC) and could almost be renamed an 'industry life cycle.' Of course not only industries could be considered here but also segments
It is a combination of the two aforementioned dimensions that helps us to use ADL for marketing decision-making. Now let's consider options in more detail. Competitive position has five main categories:
  • 1. Dominant - This is a particularly extraordinary position. Often this is associate with some form of monopoly position or customer lock-in e.g. Microsoft Windows being the dominant global operating system.
  • 2. Strong - Here companies have a lot of freedom since position in an industry is comparatively
    powerful e.g. Apple's iPod products.
  • 3. Favourable - Companies with a favourable position tend to have competitive strengths in segments of a fragmented market place. No single global player controls all segments. Here product strengths and geographical advantages come into play.
  • 4. Tenable - Here companies may face erosion by stronger competitors that have a favourable, strong or competitive position. It is difficult for them to compete since they do not have a sustainable competitive advantage.
  • 5. Weak - As the term suggests companies in this undesirable space are in an unenviable position. Of course there are opportunities to change and improve, and therefore to take an organization to a more favourable, strong or even dominant position.
From here the strategic position of an organisation can be established. Managers then need to decide upon the best strategic direction for the business. For example they might use a Gap Analysis. According to ADL, there are six generic categories of strategy that could be employed by individual SBU's:
  • Market strategies.
  • Product strategies.
  • Management and systems strategies.
  • Technology strategies.
  • Retrenchment strategies.
  • Operations strategies.
by Mkt Teachers